Why: It is hard for me to say I enjoy suspense novels because I associate them with being scary. That said, I truly love mysteries and the drama of putting pieces together to figure out how the story will play out. Natchez Burning and the other two books in the trilogy (Bone Tree and Mississippi Blood) made my TBR list because they have combined my elements of “suspense” with – you guessed it – a historical setting. To top it off, these novels revolve around race relations which has been a topic of choice for me lately.
“If a man is forced to choose between the truth and his father, only a fool chooses the truth.”
The Story: On a very basic, non-spoiler level, Natchez Burning is a tale of the lasting horror that occurred in The South during the Civil Rights era. It shares the turmoil Natchez Mayor Penn Cage faces when his stoic father, a prominent physician and military veteran, is accused of murder. With the past bleeding into the present, Penn works with local journalist Henry Sexton and his fiance Caitlin Masters to solve not only his father’s case, but a litany of cold cases long abandoned by the rest of the world.
…to yearn for ignorance is to embrace the wishful thinking of a child. For once the stone hits the surface of the pond, the ripples never really stop. The waves diminish, and all seems to return to its previous state, but that’s an illusion.
Opinion: I had my doubts when I began this book. It starts off very heavy. Made it hard to imagine tackling 600 more pages! Then, it got me. I love Iles’ writing style. It is uncensored writing that feels genuine and displays an honest representation of the hell that so many went though.There are passages I felt got a little verbose, but then they made perfect sense later. The plot is intricate but moves along. Best of all, I didn’t figure it out. Oh, I had theories! I had plenty of theories! I enjoyed that I was still surprised with the twists and turns, though. To me, that is the sign of a great mystery. Leaves me itching to start The Bone Tree!
What happened next unfolded with the unreality of dreams.
Recommendation: I highly recommend this book for fellow mystery lovers. Reading it is not quick or easy, though. I can’t imagine reading this during commutes or short, segmented sessions. It takes time to digest and comprehend the relationships.The complexities are worth the struggle, however! I felt immersed in the story, felt the pangs as if it was my own family. Another review claims this resembles classic literary fiction, and I can’t disagree. Not recommended for the faint of heart or those unwilling to dig into the past.
“…don’t ask me anything you don’t want the answer to.”
Journaling Prompts: (I like to include questions with each of my reviews, but it is even better when questions are provided! These come from publisher HarperCollins reading guide.)
- One critic described Greg Iles’ writing in Natchez Burning as William Faulkner “for the Breaking Bad generation.” How does Natchez Burning fit into that comparison?
- There are many secrets described in this book. Dr. Tom Cage has held one from his past for decades, and it’s one of the most damaging in the novel. How does Penn deal with it in the present?
- Discuss the sociological and political landscape in Natchez, Mississippi, from the turbulent 1960s as well as the present. Does this novel show any progress in these areas, or are the characters doomed to suffer from their own personal histories?
- Penn is an attorney, and his father is a physician. What is the impact of these professions on the plot, and do they produce limitations for these men?
- There are several twists and turns that keep the plot driving forward. What do you think is the most significant plot twist, and is Penn able to recover from and move beyond it?
- Natchez Burning is unlike most thrillers in its length and the fact that it will remind some of classic literary fiction. Which thrillers would you compare it to?
- What do you think will happen to Penn Cage and his family in the second and third novels in this trilogy, The Bone Tree and Mississippi Blood?
- What do you think makes Natchez Burning such a recognizable Southern tale? Is there a unique, recognizable quality to Southern novels and novelists?